Welcome to Cayuga Hardware LLC

Cayuga, Indiana’s source for all your hardware needs!

"Now this is the way a hardware store should be" is a comment we hear a lot.

Cayuga Hardware LLC is the answer to your all you do-it-yourself needs. Just take a look at a short list of products we carry.


Valspar paint, Wooster brushes, caulk, vinyl blinds, canning, cleaning and camping supplies. Hand tools, welding, automotive, fasteners, electrical and plumming supplies, and pet and lawn and garden products.


Cayuga Hardware LLC so appreciates your business we work hard to outdo any and all when it comes to customer satisfaction.


Why go anywhere else?

For professional advice on your building project, call or
come in to visit us!

Man standing in front of a wall full of tools

We are always available to help you find exactly what
you need and can offer recommendations on supplies for your specific product. Looking for something specific and can’t find it? If we do not have what you are looking for, we can order it for you! When you’re ready to
work on your home or business and need supplies,
call or come visit the friendly, professional staff at
Cayuga Hardware LLC.

Cayuga Hardware LLC

PO Box 187
100 North Patterson Street
Cayuga, Indiana 47928

Phone: 765-492-3000
Email: cayugahardware@att.net

Hours of Operation:

Monday to Saturday
8:00 AM – 5:00 PM


Copyright © Cayuga Hardware LLC,
2012. All rights reserved.

Cayuga Hardware LLC - Call us Today 765-492-3000